DIY Moving vs. Hiring Movers: Colorado Springs Cost Analysis

One of the biggest decisions you’ll make during a move is whether to do it yourself or hire professional movers. Both options have their place, and the right choice depends on your budget, your timeline, and what you value most.

At iHaul iMove, we’ve been helping Colorado Springs families move for 17+ years, and we’ve seen the aftermath of both successful DIY moves and ones that went sideways. Here’s an honest cost comparison to help you decide.

The True Cost of DIY Moving

DIY moving seems like the obvious money-saver, but most people dramatically underestimate the true cost. Here’s what you’ll actually spend:

Truck Rental

Renting a moving truck is the most visible DIY expense. Depending on the truck size and rental period, you’re looking at a significant daily rate plus mileage charges. Weekend and month-end rentals (when most leases end) often cost more due to demand.

Fuel

Moving trucks get poor gas mileage — typically 8-12 miles per gallon. For a local move across Colorado Springs, fuel costs are manageable. For a longer move to areas like Monument or Castle Rock, fuel adds up quickly.

Equipment and Supplies

• Moving blankets, dollies, and hand trucks (rental or purchase)
• Packing tape, boxes, bubble wrap, and packing paper
• Furniture sliders and straps
• Floor protection materials

Insurance

The basic insurance included with most truck rentals covers damage to the rental truck only — not your belongings, not your home’s walls and floors, and not injuries to your volunteer helpers.

The Hidden Costs People Forget

• Pizza and drinks for friends — The traditional “payment” for moving help
• Time off work — A DIY move often takes 2-3 times longer than a professional one
• Injury risk — Back injuries, dropped items, and strained muscles are extremely common
• Property damage — Doorframes, walls, banisters, and floors frequently get damaged during DIY moves
• Broken or damaged items — Without professional padding and loading techniques, furniture and fragile items are at higher risk

The Cost of Hiring Professional Movers

Professional moving costs vary based on home size, distance, time of year, and services needed. While we don’t publish fixed rates (because every move is unique), here’s what professional service includes:

What’s Included in a Professional Move

• Trained movers — Experienced, background-checked professionals
• Truck and fuel — No rental hassles or gas calculations
• Furniture padding and wrapping — Every piece protected before loading
• Floor and wall protection — Carpet shield, red runners, and door frame guards
• Loading expertise — Proper stacking, weight distribution, and securing
• Furniture disassembly and reassembly — Beds, desks, shelving units
• Basic liability coverage — Protection for your belongings
• Speed and efficiency — What takes you all day takes professionals a few hours

What You Won’t Get with DIY

Professional movers bring something you can’t replicate: experience. They know how to navigate tight staircases, protect hardwood floors, maneuver heavy furniture through narrow doorways, and load a truck so nothing shifts during transport. With 700+ 5-star reviews, our team has refined these skills over thousands of moves.

Side-by-Side Comparison

When DIY Moving Makes Sense

We’ll be honest — there are situations where DIY is the right call:

• Very small moves — A few boxes and light furniture to a nearby location
• No heavy furniture — If everything fits in a personal vehicle, a truck rental isn’t worth it
• Tight budget with flexible time — If money is tight but you have plenty of time and able-bodied help
• Short distance — Moving within the same apartment complex or across the street

When Hiring Movers Is Worth Every Penny

Professional movers are the smart choice when:

• You have heavy or valuable furniture — Pianos, antiques, gun safes, large appliances
• Stairs are involved — Carrying furniture up or down stairs is the #1 cause of moving injuries
• You’re on a tight timeline — Movers complete in hours what DIY takes all day
• You have a large home — 3+ bedrooms with a full household of belongings
• You’re moving long-distance — Cross-town or cross-country, logistics matter
• You want peace of mind — Knowing your belongings are protected and insured

The Hybrid Approach: Best of Both Worlds

You don’t have to choose all-or-nothing. Many Colorado Springs families use a hybrid approach:

• You handle: Packing boxes, decluttering, organizing, and cleaning
• We handle: Heavy furniture, appliances, loading, transport, and unloading

This approach can save you money on packing services while ensuring the heavy, risky work is done by professionals. Our labor-only moving service is perfect for this.

The Risk Factor: What DIY Movers Don’t Talk About

Here’s something the truck rental companies won’t tell you: moving is one of the most injury-prone activities homeowners undertake. Common injuries include:

• Lower back strains from lifting heavy items incorrectly
• Herniated discs from repetitive lifting
• Dropped items causing foot, leg, or toe injuries
• Falls from truck ramps, stairs, or slippery walkways
• Cuts and scrapes from sharp edges on furniture and boxes

Professional movers are trained in proper lifting techniques, use specialized equipment like shoulder straps and appliance dollies, and work as a coordinated team. The risk of injury drops dramatically.

Get a Free Comparison Quote

Still not sure which option is right for you? Here’s what we suggest: get a free estimate from iHaul iMove and compare it to your DIY costs. You might be surprised how close the numbers are — and how much stress, time, and risk you can eliminate by going with professionals.

Call 719-357-5865 or request your free quote online. We’ll give you a transparent, no-obligation estimate for your specific move.

edit_noteGet Your Free Quote

iHaul iMove has been helping Colorado Springs families move smarter for over 17 years. Learn about our residential moving services or browse all service areas we cover.